Application Evaluation - SCORING SHEET

Name of Organisation: _____________________________________________________	Reference Number: _______________________
Project Title: _____________________________________________________________
CRITERIA	WEIGHTING	COMMENTS	SCORE
PART A – DELIVERY OF OUTCOMES AND SERVICE REQUIREMENTS (Threshold 60%)
Project Aims and Objectives (Ref Q14 & 21)	Suggested (20)
Project Correspondence to specification, Priorities/Targets (Ref Q15, Q11 & Q19)	Suggested (20)
Project Actions, Timescale and Outcomes (Ref Q15, Q16, Q17 & Q18)	Suggested (20)
Needs Identification (Ref Q12, Q13 & Q20)	Suggested (20)
Beneficiaries, Inequalities in Health & Target Social Exclusion (Ref Q12 & Q21)	Suggested (10)
Community/User Involvement(Ref Q22)	Suggested (10)
Total Score – Part A	100

PART B – ABILITY TO DELIVER SERVICE OUTCOMES INCLUDING QUALITY ISSUES (Threshold 60%)
Is corporate accountability within the organisation clear & appropriate to the needs, size and complexity of organisation (see organisation chart demonstrating management structure and accounting arrangements for the project) (Ref Q5&6) Financial Management (Q7 – Q9)	Suggested (20)
Project Management ability, method of sharing experience and influencing policy / practice etc (Ref Q20, Q24, Q26, Q27, Q28 Q31)	Suggested (30)
Sustainability, exit strategy, match or related funding (Ref Q23, Q25, Q27, Q28 & Q29)	Suggested (25)
Monitoring and Evaluation (Ref Q12 & Q16)	Suggested (25)
Total Score – Part B	100
PART C - COSTS & VALUE FOR MONEY (Q29) (Threshold 60%)
Clarity of Costs & rationale for proposed budget	Suggested (40)
Reasonableness of costs	Suggested (20)
Value for money – productivity to be delivered for price	Suggested (40)
TOTAL SCORE – Part C	100

Score Summary	-	Part A	Threshold	60%	Score awarded

Part B	Threshold	60%	Score awarded

Part C	Threshold	60%	Score awarded	Cumulative Score

< 180 unsatisfactory, 180 -230 adequate, 231 – 280 Good, 281 -300 excellent

Signed by Evaluation Scoring Panel

_____________________________	___________________________

Signature	Designation

_____________________________	___________________________

Signature	Designation

_____________________________	___________________________

Signature	Designation

_____________________________	___________________________

Signature	Designation

_____________________________	___________________________

Signature	Designation